Submission 563
Mr Carl Gopalkrishnan
Submitter group: Individuals.
Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
An Australian artist argues copyright protects human creativity and independence beyond income, and supports retaining existing protections. Describes resistance to AI as national resilience and asks Parliament to recognise creativity independent of AI as a national capability. The attached experiment describes barriers from AI's speed and defaults, and useful collaboration after sustained changes preserving artistic judgement.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues copyright supports artists' income, control over their work, decisions about sharing and use, and refusal of unacceptable uses.
Copyright is not simply a mechanism for getting artists paid. It helps us retain control over our work, decide what we share, negotiate how it is used and refuse uses we do not accept.
Argues that creative-industry measures of works, employment, markets and economic activity cannot capture the full range of creativity and its social benefits.
The term creative industries is itself contested among artists. It measures our contribution largely through identifiable works, employment, markets and economic activity. Yet these measures cannot account for the full range of ways creativity operates in society, or the benefits it produces.
Says artists' independence in challenging conventions, commercial pressures and institutions is a skill set Australia needs as AI becomes embedded.
Artists have been practising this for centuries. We challenge conventions, resist commercial pressures, question institutions and sometimes refuse to make what others want us to make. That independence is a skill set Australia needs as AI becomes more deeply embedded in our lives.
Describes slowing down the attached experiment through a script and working with AI as actors as helpful, while saying it remains too fast outside that setting.
Outside it still goes too fast. I’m going to slow down: let’s open up the script. Then it becomes the normal actor I’m working with. It becomes the series of actors. It’s really helpful.
Says, in the attached recorded conversation, that human-in-the-loop oversight is a pointless argument if the system moves faster than any human can match, so that everything goes invisible.
When they talk about the human in the loop, that’s really a bit of a pointless argument if the system is going so fast that no human can match it in speed. Of course everything goes invisible.
Asks Parliament to recognise creativity independent of AI as a national capability whose supporting rights deserve protection.
I am asking it to recognise that creativity independent of AI is itself a national capability, and that the rights which help sustain that independence deserve protection.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Consider artists' capacity to resist technological change beyond copyright's economic, remuneration and productivity dimensions.
Accepting technological change doesn’t mean surrendering our capacity to resist it. I think this is something the Committee needs to consider carefully, because copyright is being discussed largely in terms of economics, remuneration and productivity.
Keep existing copyright protections in place rather than weakening them to accommodate AI corporations.
Australia's existing copyright laws provide important protections for artists. I support keeping those protections in place, rather than weakening them to accommodate AI corporations.
Examine more closely the concepts used to understand creativity and its protection as technological capabilities outpace legal language.
The challenge is not that copyright should be discarded, but that the concepts through which we understand creativity and its protection need closer examination. When technological capabilities change faster than our legal language can describe them, we need ways to recognise the consequences before they become irreversible.
Recognise creativity independent of AI as a national capability whose supporting rights deserve protection.
I am asking it to recognise that creativity independent of AI is itself a national capability, and that the rights which help sustain that independence deserve protection.
Recognise that the pace of technological change has outpaced the legal tools used in this inquiry.
I am asking Parliament to recognise that the pace of technological change has outpaced the legal tools used in this inquiry.
In the Blake Society's supporting letter: consider artistic authorship, visibility, speed and human agency, and recognise the international relevance of Australian independent artists' experiences.
Questions of artistic authorship, visibility, speed and human agency deserve serious consideration by the Committee. We hope the Committee will recognise that the experiences being documented by independent artists in Australia have international relevance for writers, artists and cultural communities facing similar challenges.