AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 565

Mr Nathan Brenner

Submitter group: Individuals.

Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Argues from experience managing music artists that standard recording contracts already grant labels broad rights to use recordings with AI, alongside long-standing royalty and accounting problems; attaches a redacted standard agreement. Calls for statutory reform of copyright, training-data transparency, minimum streaming and AI income shares and collective enforcement. Opposes ownership of genres, moods or chord progressions.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that standard recording contracts already let labels use recordings with AI through 'catch-all' clauses written before AI existed.

    In short, the artist has already signed a contract that lets the record company use their recordings with AI, written years before the AI existed, as a new technology ‘catch-all’ clause.

  2. Argues that licensing permission from a rights holder does not show that the recorded creator had bargaining power, adequate payment or the ability to inspect accounts.

    The word "licensed" has to stop ending the conversation, because permission from a rights holder does not establish that the recorded creator had bargaining power, adequate payment, or any ability to inspect the accounting.

  3. Argues that copyright should be rebuilt around what a human creator keeps when their work trains AI systems.

    Copyright must be rebuilt from first principles, here and internationally, around one question: what does a human creator keep when their work trains a system that generates competing material at scale?

  4. Argues that transparency about training should carry legal force, including a duty on developers to keep auditable records.

    Transparency has to carry legal force, with a duty on the developer to keep auditable records and produce them when a claim is raised, so a creator is not left to reverse-engineer a commercial system just to begin asking.

  5. Argues that Australia is an outlier compared with other countries' legislation and court outcomes.

    Measured against what other countries have actually legislated and won in court, Australia is the outlier, and the gap is severe.

  6. Argues that the packaging deduction was never removed from artist royalties, and that the company keeps it although the cost it was invented to cover has disappeared.

    But the packaging deduction was never removed, because the artist's rate was set on the old frame and nobody rewrote it. The company keeps the deduction, while the cost it was invented to cover has disappeared.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Rebuild copyright nationally and internationally around creators’ retained rights when AI generates competing material; impose acquisition, training, deployment and distribution obligations, specifying uses needing permission and narrowly bounded exceptions.

    Copyright must be rebuilt from first principles, here and internationally, around one question: what does a human creator keep when their work trains a system that generates competing material at scale? A rebuilt system should impose obligations at each stage of the pipeline, acquisition, training, deployment, and distribution, and should state plainly which uses require permission and which merit a narrowly bounded exception.

  2. Preserve a core of rights for creators through any transfer of commercial ownership: information about machine uses, enforceable accounting, and protection against unauthorised commercial replicas of their person.

    It must preserve, through any transfer of commercial ownership, a core of rights for the creator: information about machine uses, enforceable accounting, and protection against an unauthorised commercial replica of their person.

  3. Require developers to keep auditable records and produce them when a claim is raised, rather than leaving creators to reconstruct commercial systems.

    Transparency has to carry legal force, with a duty on the developer to keep auditable records and produce them when a claim is raised, so a creator is not left to reverse-engineer a commercial system just to begin asking.

  4. Provide accessible claims procedures, workable collective enforcement and a standing public authority able to investigate persistent conduct.

    Enforcement must stop being a luxury a major catalogue can afford and a mortgage payer cannot, which means access to claims procedures, workable collective enforcement, and a public authority able to investigate persistent conduct.

  5. Prevent ownership of a genre, mood, chord progression or the broad idea of sounding influenced.

    No one should gain ownership of a genre, a mood, or a chord progression, or the broad idea of sounding influenced, because handing a veto over culture to a giant catalogue owner would be as bad as giving a technology company unchecked access.

  6. Pursue shared international minimums for transparency, authorisation, remedies and recognition of creators' claims, with protections that follow commercial activity across borders.

    a credible framework needs shared minimums for transparency, authorisation, remedies and the recognition of creators' claims, with protections that follow the commercial activity across borders

  7. Give working creators, smaller businesses, researchers and the public a seat before the Committee settles the important provisions, rather than after.

    give working creators, smaller businesses, researchers, and the public a seat before the Committee settles the important provisions, rather than after

  8. Void a blanket advance consent that covers every future act and every future work.

    On the machine: void a blanket advance consent that covers every future act and every future work

  9. Void the 'hereafter devised' grant so that no new use proceeds without fresh consent.

    void the "hereafter devised" grant so no new use proceeds without fresh consent

  10. Extend moral rights to sound recordings.

    extend moral rights to sound recordings

  11. Make training-data disclosure a legal obligation.

    make training-data disclosure a legal obligation.

  12. Give performers a statutory minimum share of streaming and AI income that no contract can strip to zero.

    give performers a statutory minimum share of streaming and AI income that no contract can strip to zero

  13. Require every dollar from AI licensing or litigation to be accounted for to the creators who generated it.

    require every dollar from AI licensing or litigation to be accounted for to the creators who generated it

  14. Give creators an uncapped audit right not run through the company whose books are being checked.

    give creators an uncapped audit right not run through the company whose books are being checked

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide