Submission 69
RS9 Systems Pty Ltd
Submitter group: Companies.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
RS9 Systems, which develops government operations software and says the reforms would expand opportunities for businesses such as itself, argues large-scale automation of routine government work should be a national priority and that procurement is a major barrier. It sets out eleven recommendations on direct engagement, evaluation deadlines, national prequalification, pilot-to-production and evidence reuse.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
RS9 argues that Australia should make large-scale automation of routine government operations a national priority, supported by procurement arrangements.
Australia should make the large-scale automation of routine government operations a national priority. AI can expand public sector capacity, improve service delivery and create a substantial domestic market for Australian technology. Achieving this requires procurement arrangements that support implementation across agencies and sustained operation beyond a pilot.
RS9 says that in its experience procurement is a major barrier, including reference requirements, uncertain evaluation periods and repeated qualification.
RS9's experience selling technology to government is that procurement remains a major barrier to this opportunity. Existing deployments can carry little weight against requirements for multiple government references. Evaluation periods are uncertain, successful pilots may require a fresh tender before they can proceed, and suppliers repeat qualification across jurisdictions.
RS9 says mandatory requirements for multiple government deployments or certifications can exclude otherwise capable suppliers before evaluation.
We repeatedly encounter mandatory requirements for several deployments of the same solution in Australian government, or for the tenderer to hold ISO 27001 certification, SOC 2 assurance or an IRAP assessment. These requirements can exclude an otherwise capable supplier before its solution is evaluated.
RS9 says duplication imposes costs on suppliers and buyers and limits the transfer of proven systems between jurisdictions.
The resulting duplication imposes costs on suppliers and buyers and limits the transfer of proven systems between jurisdictions.
RS9 argues that government purchasing can support Australian technology capability while improving public services.
Government purchasing can support the development and retention of Australian technology capability while improving public services.
RS9 argues that council services are a practical way to bring AI benefits to suburbs and regions, provided councils get access to buying arrangements and support.
Their services are a practical way to bring the benefits of AI to the suburbs and regions, as term of reference (b) asks. Councils need access to the buying arrangements and support to meet the requirements that come with them.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Add a production government reference and Australian data residency as grounds for limited tender under Commonwealth Procurement Rules paragraph 10.3, with an equivalent NSW provision.
Add a production government reference and Australian data residency as a ground for limited tender under paragraph 10.3 of the Commonwealth Procurement Rules, with an equivalent NSW provision.
Raise direct-engagement limits no further than each jurisdiction's covered-procurement ceiling; in NSW, move from the $250,000 SME limit towards $680,000 excluding GST.
Raise direct-engagement limits no further than the existing covered-procurement ceiling in each jurisdiction. In NSW, that would mean moving from the $250,000 SME limit towards the $680,000 ceiling excluding GST.
Make Exemption 17 routine for multi-year SME operational technology contracts up to $500,000 including GST, retaining value-for-money, applicable Indigenous Procurement Policy and Division 1 requirements; qualifying multi-year terms should not preclude direct engagement.
Commonwealth Exemption 17 already allows direct engagement of an SME up to $500,000 including GST, subject to value for money and applicable Indigenous Procurement Policy requirements. Make this a routine pathway for multi-year operational technology within that limit. Keep the Division 1 requirements in place. A multi-year term should not itself rule out direct engagement where the whole contract qualifies.
Require a published tender decision deadline of 60 days from tender close, published reasons for the outcome and public reporting against the standard.
Require a published decision deadline of 60 days from tender close, published reasons for the outcome and public reporting against the standard.
Create a national AI operations supplier panel for Commonwealth, state and local engagement without fresh tender; require mutual recognition including NSW SCM0020, Victorian eServices Register, Digital Marketplace Panel 2 and Local Buy.
Create a national panel through which Commonwealth, state and local buyers can engage a prequalified AI operations supplier without a fresh tender. Require mutual recognition between existing schemes, including NSW SCM0020, the Victorian eServices Register, Digital Marketplace Panel 2 and Local Buy.
Give the national panel a supplier register, evidence submission process and buyer catalogue, with recorded listing decisions open to inspection, running on Australian infrastructure and operated by an Australian supplier already applying the national framework in practice.
The panel should have a supplier register, an evidence submission process and a catalogue buyers can use. Its own listing decisions should be recorded and open to inspection. It should run on Australian infrastructure and be operated by an Australian supplier already applying the national framework in practice.
Set panel eligibility requiring Australian ownership, Australian storage and processing of government data, no use of government data to train models, and an accountable supplier representative in Australia.
Eligibility should require Australian ownership, government data stored and processed in Australia, no use of government data to train models, and an accountable supplier representative in Australia.
Require panel suppliers to demonstrate twelve months of continuous production operation in an Australian government body, with exportable, verifiable decision records; self-assessment alone should not qualify.
Suppliers should also demonstrate twelve months of continuous production operation in an Australian government body, with records of individual decisions that the host agency can export and verify. Self-assessment alone should not qualify a supplier.
Allow a paid pilot bought below threshold to convert to a full contract without re-tendering when it meets criteria published before the pilot starts.
Allow a paid pilot bought below threshold to convert to a full contract without re-tendering when it meets criteria published before the pilot starts.
Replace mandatory multiple-government-deployment requirements or unaffordable certifications with a live-system decision-record test, in a published format, verified by the host agency; apply the same test to large firms.
Prohibit mandatory requirements for multiple existing government deployments, or certifications beyond a small supplier's means, and replace them with a practical capability test: produce a record of an individual decision from a live system, in a published format, for verification by the host agency. Requiring several government deployments can exclude a supplier that has delivered one successfully. A test of the system itself would allow that supplier to compete for its next contract. The same test should apply to large firms.
Allow reliance on an Australian government deployment's evidence only where decision records meet national-framework requirements; limit to three years from first award, cap value, publish transferred price basis and restore competition at renewal.
Where a system operates in an Australian government body and its decision records meet the national framework's requirements, allow another body to rely on that evidence in place of a fresh evaluation. Limit the pathway to three years from the first award, cap the contract value, carry across and publish the price basis, and restore full competition at renewal.
Give priority to funding agencies to run an AI operation from start to finish, with officer approval for consequential decisions and a published evidence record.
Give priority to funding agencies to run an AI operation from start to finish, with officer approval for consequential decisions and a published evidence record.
Tie Commonwealth grants to states and councils, including planning and digital transformation grants, to use of prequalified suppliers and the national framework's operational controls.
Tie Commonwealth grants to states and councils, including planning and digital transformation grants, to the use of prequalified suppliers and the operational controls in the national framework.
Adopt a national format for recording decisions made with machine assistance, accepted across jurisdictions.
Adopt a national format for recording decisions made with machine assistance, accepted across jurisdictions.
Publish standard national AI contract clauses covering officer oversight, inspection rights, data residency, notification of model changes and record retention.
10. Publish standard AI contract clauses Provide clauses for national use covering officer oversight, inspection rights, data residency, notification of model changes and record retention.
Extend the national framework and procurement pathways explicitly to councils, with Commonwealth support for the smallest councils to use them.
Extend the national framework and these procurement pathways explicitly to councils, with Commonwealth support for the smallest councils to use them.
Recommend a coordinated programme of procurement reform to accelerate AI adoption across Australian government, with the Commonwealth leading through its own purchasing arrangements and working with states and councils on common qualification, reusable evidence and access to proven Australian systems.
We ask the committee to recommend a coordinated programme of procurement reform to accelerate AI adoption across Australian government. The Commonwealth should lead through its own purchasing arrangements and work with states and councils on common qualification, reusable evidence and access to proven Australian systems.
Set a national ambition that government run an increasing share of routine work autonomously, retain officer responsibility for consequential decisions, and report annually on progress.
We also ask it to set a national ambition: government should run an increasing share of routine work autonomously, retain officer responsibility for consequential decisions, and report annually on progress.