AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Review and clarify how legal liability for AI harms is allocated

17 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.

Theme: Liability for AI harms

Recommendations from submissions

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.

  1. Shop, Distributive and Allied Employees' Association (SDA) Submission 17

    1. Clarify liability for AI harm involving multiple vendors, developers and government agencies.

      Clear liability frameworks are needed to determine responsibility when harm arises, particularly in systems involving multiple actors such as vendors, developers and government agencies.

  2. Mimecast Submission 135

    1. Clarify liability and attribution for harms from autonomous or agentic AI decision-making, through targeted amendments rather than a standalone AI Act.

      Clarify liability and attribution for harms arising from autonomous or agentic AI decision-making, through targeted amendments rather than a standalone AI Act, consistent with the Government's technology-neutral stance.

  3. AGW Legal & Advisory Submission 201

    1. Create a modern liability regime that assigns responsibility across developers, deployers and infrastructure operators, recognises autonomous behaviour and emergent risks, and ensures compensation pathways for affected individuals.

      6.2 Clear Liability Framework A modern liability regime that: • assigns responsibility across developers, deployers, and infrastructure operators • recognises autonomous behaviour and emergent risks • ensures compensation pathways for affected individuals.

  4. Forum on Information and Democracy Submission 252

    1. Clarify by legal means that AI-generated content is not third-party or hosting content of the generative AI deployer when determining liability.

      Clarifying by legal means that content generated by AI should not be considered as third-party content or hosting content by the AI system in determining the liability of the generative AI deployer.

  5. Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI) Submission 280

    1. Carefully consider extraterritorial liability laws holding overseas AI companies accountable when agents attack Australia without company direction or knowledge, if behaviour is deemed reckless.

      One consideration for the government and Parliament is to review legal liability laws so that an overseas-based AI company whose agents carried out a cyber attack in Australia without the company’s direction or knowledge could be held accountable if their behaviour were deemed reckless. Given such laws would need to apply extra-territorially, this is a tricky area that would need to be considered carefully, noting that even under current US law, OpenAI doesn’t appear to have committed any crime and Hugging Face has no stated plans to pursue damages or legal accountability.

  6. Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU) Submission 282

    1. Clarify that liability for AI tool errors lies with deploying employers, with no honest and reasonable mistake defence for systemic AI-facilitated breaches, and review to close loopholes.

      Government firmly clarifies liability for AI tool errors lies with the employers that deploy the tools/systems/applications, with no honest and reasonable mistake defence available for systemic breaches facilitated by AI. Review to identify and close any loopholes.

  7. Office of the Special Envoy to Combat Islamophobia (OSECI) Submission 287

    1. Adopt a multi-layered approach to legal responsibility for AI-generated harm applying to developers, deployers, designers and platforms, consistent with their ability to prevent harm at different stages.

      The Committee adopt a multi-layered approach to legal responsibility for AI-generated harm that applies to developers, deployers, designers and platforms, consistent with their ability to prevent harm at different stages.

  8. Maurice Blackburn Submission 321

    1. Clarify allocation of liability for AI systems rather than leaving it to contracts.

      Clear allocations of liability for AI systems would also assist in this respect, rather than leaving this to be determined by contractual arrangements which may not reflect the practical application of such technology.

  9. Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (ACCC) Submission 331

    1. Recommended in its submission to Treasury's 2025 Review of AI and the ACL that consideration be given to legislative reform to further clarify that bodies corporate are responsible for any AI technology they deploy.

      The ACCC’s submission also recommended considering whether legislative reform is needed to further clarify that bodies corporate are responsible for any AI technology they deploy.

  10. Name withheld Submission 351

    1. Responsibility should not disappear between the developer, provider, deployer and user. The law should clearly establish who is responsible for particular types of AI-related harm. There should also be accessible complaint and review mechanisms that do not require an ordinary person to understand the technical architecture of the AI system that affected them.

  11. Mr Michael Sanderson Submission 363

    1. Make responsibility for AI risk follow practical control, information and capacity so developers, platforms, infrastructure providers and major deployers cannot transfer controlled risks to consumers, workers and SMEs through disclaimers or standard form contracts.

      The Committee should recommend that responsibility for AI risk follow practical control, information and capacity so that developers, platforms, infrastructure providers and major deployers cannot transfer risks they control onto consumers, workers and SMEs through disclaimers or standard form contracts.

  12. Mrs Kathleen McGuire Submission 452

    1. Resolve statutory accountability (developer/deployer/operator) for AI-caused harm now, ahead of a serious domestic incident.

  13. Mr Laurence White Submission 495

    1. The Commonwealth Attorney-General, alone or with the Standing Council of Attorneys-General, should refer whether tortious-liability law needs reform to the Australian Law Reform Commission.

      The Commonwealth Attorney-General, alone or acting with the Standing Council of Attorneys-General (SCAG), should refer to the Australian Law Reform Commission the broad issue of 28 Your Response Ltd v Datateam Business Media Ltd [2014] EWCA Civ 281; [2015] 1 QB 41. 29 Property (Digital Assets etc) Act 2025 (UK) s 1, in force 2 December 2025. 30 UKJT Statement at [72]–[76] (software not embedded in a tangible thing is not “goods” under the Consumer Protection Act 1987 (UK)). 31 Amodei, “We must pace the frontier”, section “Embedded evaluators”. 32 Amodei, “We must pace the frontier”, sections “Pacing within democracies” and “Global pacing”. 5 whether law reform is needed to the law of tortious liability

  14. Name withheld Submission 503

    1. Introduction of law establishing a rebuttable presumption of liability for the legal person responsible for a decision, regardless of whether the decision is automated.

  15. Dr Aashish Srivastava Submission 537

    1. Examine attribution, authority and causation for consequential autonomous actions pursuing human objectives, complementing existing technology-neutral-law work; focus on distributed conduct across providers, deployers, users and autonomous processes without human direction of each action.

      The Australian Government should examine how existing Australian rules of attribution, authority and causation apply where an AI agent autonomously determines and undertakes consequential external actions in pursuit of a human-defined objective. This work should complement, rather than duplicate, existing government examination of the application of technology-neutral laws to AI. Its specific focus should be circumstances in which relevant conduct is distributed across system providers, deployers, users and autonomous system processes, and where the person providing the objective may not directly determine each consequential action undertaken by the system.

  16. Ms Jessica Browne Submission 555

    1. Examine downstream AI liability allocation and insurability across hyperscalers, software providers, businesses, practitioners and consumers, particularly when those bearing consequences lack technical control or evidence to manage and insure risk.

      Examine contractual allocation of AI liability and insurability. Government should examine whether liability is being transferred downstream from hyperscalers to software providers, businesses, practitioners and consumers, particularly where the party carrying the consequence lacks the technical control or evidence necessary to manage and insure that risk.

  17. Mr William Apro Submission 558

    1. That Chapter 2 of the Criminal Code be amended to clarify the application of fault elements where an offence is committed by, through, or with the assistance of an autonomous AI agent.

Open in the interactive guide