AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Complete a gap analysis of existing laws before introducing AI-specific obligations

17 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.

Theme: Adequacy of existing laws

Recommendations from submissions

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.

  1. Atlassian Submission 89

    1. Properly assess and, where needed, bolster existing laws through further reforms.

      The need to properly assess and, where needed, bolster our existing laws, including through further reforms.

  2. Stripe Submission 163

    1. First assess whether there are gaps in the existing payments regime or its objectives, and only then consider targeted changes, rather than assuming a new AI-specific payment category or separate regime is necessary.

      Policymakers should exercise caution before assuming that a new AI-specific category of payment services, or a separate horizontal regime for agentic commerce, is necessary. Instead, the priority should be to assess whether there are any gaps in the existing regime or regulatory objectives that aren’t being met. Only then should targeted changes be considered.

  3. NCC Group Submission 185

    1. Conduct a structured gap analysis of existing regimes against real AI use cases, testing whether responsibility and preventative, monitoring, incident-response and redress obligations are adequate for high-impact AI.

      The appropriate task is a structured gap analysis against real AI use cases, testing whether existing regimes clearly allocate responsibility and provide adequate preventative, monitoring, incident-response and redress obligations for high-impact AI.

  4. National Farmers' Federation Submission 188

    1. Publish the existing-law, regulator, standards and initiatives map before recommending new obligations.

      Publish a clear map of existing laws, regulators, standards and government initiatives relevant to AI before recommending new obligations.

  5. Digital Economy Council of Australia Submission 239

    1. Settle coordination and disclosure before identifying residual regulatory gaps against deployment data.

      The right sequence is to settle coordination and disclosure, then identify any residual gap against reported data rather than assert it in advance.

  6. Employment Hero Submission 249

    1. Before introducing AI-specific regulation, complete a gap analysis of existing legal frameworks (privacy, consumer, work health and safety, anti-discrimination) in consultation with industry to identify genuine gaps.

      Before introducing AI-specific regulation, complete a gap analysis of existing legal frameworks, including privacy, consumer, work health and safety and anti-discrimination law, in consultation with industry, to identify where genuine gaps exist rather than assuming new AI-specific rules are the default response.

  7. FinTech Australia Submission 250

    1. Undertake a coordinated, economy-wide review to identify genuine gaps in how existing laws apply to AI, areas of uncertainty or overlap, and legacy provisions that unnecessarily inhibit beneficial AI adoption.

      The Australian Government should undertake a coordinated, economy-wide review to identify genuine gaps in the application of existing laws to AI, areas of uncertainty or regulatory overlap, and legacy provisions that unnecessarily inhibit beneficial AI adoption.

  8. UNICEF Australia Submission 271

    1. Use existing digital reforms to make them fit for purpose for AI, then plug any gaps with new laws and regulations.

      Utilise existing digital reforms in Australia to make them fit-for-purpose for AI, then plug any gaps with new laws and regulations.

  9. Monash University Submission 277

    1. Conduct a nationally coherent, risk- and rights-based review of existing laws by AI use case and potential harm, with targeted reform where gaps cannot be addressed through existing frameworks.

      a nationally coherent, risk- and rights-based review of existing laws by AI use case and potential harm, with targeted reform where demonstrated gaps cannot be addressed through existing frameworks

  10. Business Software Alliance (BSA) Submission 285

    1. In the annexed September 2025 PC filing, endorse comprehensive gap analyses of AI risks and their coverage under existing regulatory frameworks.

      The Government should undertake a comprehensive set of “gap analyses” to understand the risks stemming from AI and whether these risks can be dealt with under existing regulatory frameworks.

  11. Centre for AI, Trust and Governance at the University of Sydney Submission 286

    1. Commission a coordinated gap analysis across privacy, critical infrastructure, copyright and content-standards regimes as they apply to AI, rather than pursuing wholesale reinvention.

      Resolve targeted regulatory and copyright gaps rather than pursuing wholesale reinvention. Commission a coordinated gap analysis across privacy, critical infrastructure, copyright and content-standards regimes as they apply to AI.

  12. Business Council of Australia (BCA) Submission 290

    1. Limit AI-specific obligations to clear and material gaps, supported by proportionate impact analysis.

      AI-specific obligations should be limited to clear and material gaps and supported by proportionate impact analysis.

      A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  13. Minerals Council of Australia (MCA) Submission 295

    1. Maintain a technology-neutral, evidence-based approach, limiting additional regulation to identified harms existing frameworks cannot manage.

      Maintain a technology-neutral and evidence-based approach to AI regulation, with any additional regulation limited to addressing identified harms that cannot be effectively managed through existing regulatory frameworks.

      A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  14. Tech Council of Australia Submission 299

    1. Publish a national AI regulatory roadmap and gap analysis clarifying how existing laws apply, identifying genuine gaps, allocating regulator responsibilities and explaining when targeted legislation or standards may be needed.

      Publish a national AI regulatory roadmap and gap analysis to clarify how existing laws apply, identify genuine gaps, allocate regulator responsibilities and explain when targeted legislation or standards may be required.

  15. Australian Banking Association (ABA) Submission 307

    1. Before new obligations on already regulated sectors, identify and publish gaps between existing law and the risk; legislate only where a gap is established.

      The ABA asks the Committee to recommend that, before new obligations are imposed on an already regulated sector, the Government identify and publish the gaps between existing law and the risk it is seeking to address and legislate only where a gap is established.

  16. Microsoft Submission 322

    1. Update existing laws where necessary and introduce new regulation for clearly identified gaps (such as frontier model governance and AI-generated content authenticity and provenance), proportionate, nationally consistent and interoperable internationally.

      regulatory reform focused on updating existing laws where necessary to ensure they are fit for purpose for the AI era (e.g. privacy reforms) and introducing new regulation for clearly identified gaps (such as frontier model governance and the authenticity and provenance of AI-generated content). Any new measures should be proportionate, nationally consistent and interoperable with emerging international approaches.

  17. Australian Retail Council (ARC) Submission 523

    1. Assess the additional risks arising from particular uses of AI and whether existing law, guidance or enforcement can address them.

      Government should apply this approach by assessing the additional risks arising from particular uses of AI and whether existing law, guidance or enforcement can address them.

Open in the interactive guide