AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Make AI developers and deployers legally liable for harm their systems cause

12 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.

Theme: Liability for AI harms

Recommendations from submissions

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.

  1. Dr Ben Saunders Submission 104

    1. Enact a provision along the proposed lines deeming AI creators responsible for actions that would give rise to a civil cause of action if performed by a natural person.

      Where an action is performed by an artificial intelligence technology, and that action would give rise to a civil cause of action if performed by a natural person, the person responsible for creating the artificial intelligence technology is taken to have committed the action.

  2. Dr Morgan Serong Submission 106

    1. Legislate to make AI companies liable for damage done by their products.

      Legislate to make AI companies liable for damage done by their products.

  3. Dr Fiona Tito Wheatland Submission 245

    1. Make AI companies legally responsible for harms and losses where they do not adequately monitor their systems for fraud, scams, deepfakes and harmful content.

      Where AI companies choose not to adequately monitor their systems for fraud, scams. deepfakes and harmful content (including but not limited to that for children and vulnerable people) they should be legally responsible for harms and losses resulting from this failure.

  4. Forum on Information and Democracy Submission 252

    1. Implement a fault-based liability regime for AI developers and deployers for system outputs, liable for failure to comply with risk mitigation, transparency and duty-of-care obligations unless evidence proves otherwise.

      Implementing a fault-based liability regime for AI developers and deployers regarding the outputs of their systems. Developers and deployers would be held liable for their failure to comply with obligations related to risk mitigation measures, transparency requirements, and duty of care, unless evidence proves otherwise.

  5. Good Ancestors Submission 257

    1. Amend consumer law so AI developers are responsible for what their models can do, including risks their systems create, without liability shifting to businesses and consumers not well placed to address them.

      Amend consumer law so that AI developers are responsible for what their models can do, including the risks their systems create. Liability should not shift to Australian businesses and consumers when they are not well placed to address those risks.

  6. Mr Nik Samoylov Submission 338

    1. Introduce strict, joint liability for AI incidents for developers and deployers.

      Introduce rules for strict liability for AI incidents for developers and deployers, jointly liable.

  7. Name withheld Submission 443

    1. That liability for non-consensual synthetic sexual imagery extend beyond the individual creator to the providers, app stores, payment processors and hosting services that make such applications available to Australians.

  8. Ms Suzy Anderson Bessell Submission 459

    1. Make clear in law that where a person instructs an AI agent and it acts illegally or harmfully, the AI developer and the person using AI are both legally responsible.

      if a person instructs an AI agent to undertake an activity and the agent carries out that instruction in an illegal or harmful way, the law should make clear that the AI developer and the person using AI are both legally responsible

  9. Mr Scott Masters Submission 473

    1. Holding AI companies legally liable for misaligned behaviour gives them a monetary incentive to solve the problem. If an AI model autonomously hacks a third party the model’s creators should be held responsible for the damage. If an AI model can be coaxed into giving terrorists instructions on producing a lethal virus its creators should be regarded as accessories to that crime.

  10. Name withheld Submission 477

    1. In particular, the Committee is requested to use this opportunity to ensure that technology companies are required by law to be liable for and address societal and human impacts - not to focus primarily only company share value - when developing, deploying, and scaling AI systems.

  11. Name withheld Submission 485

    1. Most importantly, organisations must remain legally responsible for the consequences of AI systems they develop or deploy. No company or government agency should be able to avoid accountability by claiming that “the AI made the decision.”

  12. Mr Gareth Davies Submission 505

    1. Place primary AI-conduct liability on the entity; make the Supervisor personally responsible for supervisory-architecture and governance failures, insulated from ordinary commercial direction, rather than liable for individual outputs.

      The third is the AI Supervisor, the named human officer inside the entity, carrying personal obligations for the integrity of the supervisory architecture. The Supervisor is not liable for individual AI outputs. Liability attaches instead to failures in the supervisory architecture itself, including design, monitoring and escalation systems, and to governance failure such as permitting the entity to operate outside the conditions the licence requires. The role is structurally insulated from ordinary commercial direction within the entity, in the manner of an AFSL responsible manager, a TGA responsible person, or an aviation chief pilot. 16. In legal terms, the entity bears primary liability for the AI’s conduct, while the Supervisor carries responsibility for maintaining the integrity of the governance architecture.

Open in the interactive guide