AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Guarantee a right to human review of significant automated decisions

18 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.

Theme: Automated decision-making in government

Recommendations from submissions

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.

  1. Human Technology Institute, University of Technology Sydney Submission 18

    1. Preserve accessible, appropriate review of automated decisions, including senior-official internal review, external merits review and judicial review, without reducing existing review rights.

      People should be able to seek review of automated decisions. The law should enable a person who wishes to challenge an automated decision to do so using accessible and appropriate review processes. The use of ADM should not have the effect of denying or reducing review rights for people affected by government decisions. If a decision would be reviewable if made by a human, it should also be reviewable if made through automation. This should include: - internal review by a more senior official, which is the most common, cost-effective and accessible pathway to address inaccurate or unfair decisions36 - extend to external merits review (by a tribunal) - judicial review.

  2. NableU Community Systems Incorporated Submission 66

    1. Establish minimum rights to notice, intelligible explanation, correction, human review, contestability and accountable ownership for high-impact AI-supported decisions.

      Recommendation 2. Establish minimum rights to notice, intelligible explanation, correction, human review, contestability and accountable ownership for high-impact AI-supported decisions.

  3. Infosys Submission 141

    1. Provide transparency, human review and accessible contestation or verification of AI-influenced government decisions; do not leave error identification solely to affected individuals, particularly in high-impact contexts.

      For government services, this reinforces the importance of transparency, human review mechanisms and accessible pathways through which citizens can contest or verify decisions influenced by AI systems. Responsibility for identifying errors should not rest solely with affected individuals, particularly in high- impact contexts.

  4. Pledge Human (Good Humans Good Work) Submission 182

    1. Where an automated system materially contributes to a consequential decision, ensure people know it is used, can challenge the decision and have meaningful human review, with stronger safeguards for greater consequence.

      Where an automated system materially contributes to a consequential decision, people should know that it is being used, be able to challenge the decision, and have access to meaningful human review. The greater the consequence, the stronger the safeguard should be.

  5. MEGT (Australia) Ltd Submission 194

    1. Apply AI governance to government-funded employment and social services, extending beyond transparency to human review of adverse automated decisions, drawing on Robodebt Royal Commission findings.

      MEGT Group recommends that a specific AI governance framework apply to AI used in government-funded employment and social services, extending beyond the December 2026 transparency obligation to include a right to human review of adverse automated decisions affecting individuals, drawing directly on the Robodebt Royal Commission's findings.

      A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  6. AQ Intelligence (AQI), Guardrail Technologies Australia (GTA) and First Nations Strategic Alliance (FNSA) Submission 202

    1. Provide people affected by AI decisions with transparency, a right to human review and effective redress.

      People affected by AI decisions need transparency, a right to human review, and effective redress.

      A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  7. City of Port Phillip Submission 226

    1. Require public sector agencies deploying AI to assess and mitigate impacts on vulnerable groups and maintain mechanisms for human review and appeal.

      Require public sector agencies deploying AI systems to assess and mitigate impacts on vulnerable groups and maintain mechanisms for human review and appeal.

  8. Handle My Complaint Submission 262

    1. Provide a right to obtain underlying material and require human review.

      a right to obtain the underlying material and require human review;

  9. Monash University Submission 277

    1. Enable people affected by decisions to understand when and how AI was used, challenge decisions and access timely human review and redress.

      People affected by decisions should be able to understand when and how AI has been used, challenge relevant decisions and access timely human review and redress.

  10. Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU) Submission 282

    1. Provide notification of AI-made or substantially assisted worker decisions, meaningful explanations and appeal to an authorised human decision-maker; require substantive oversight with review time included in workloads and staffing.

      Workplace ADM transparency and human oversight rights: a right to know when AI or ADM is used to make or substantially assist decisions affecting workers, a right to a meaningful explanation, and a right of appeal to a human decision-maker with genuine authority. Human oversight must be substantive, with the time required to properly review ADM outputs factored into workloads and staffing.

  11. Australian Lawyers Alliance (ALA) Submission 310

    1. Entitle people affected by a significant AI-assisted decision to prompt reconsideration by a qualified human decision-maker with all relevant material and authority to decide independently of the AI output.

      A person affected by a significant AI- assisted decision should be entitled to prompt reconsideration by an appropriately qualified human decision-maker who has access to all relevant material, is authorised to reach an independent determination and is not bound by the AI-generated output.

  12. Name withheld Submission 351

    1. Human review must not consist of an officer merely accepting an algorithmic recommendation. For significant government decisions, the responsible human decision-maker should understand: what the AI system considered; what information it relied upon; the limitations of the system; whether relevant information may be incorrect; why a particular recommendation was generated; and their authority to reject it.

  13. Ms Litsa Roberts Submission 352

    1. Give applicants and employees genuine human review where AI materially affects an adverse decision, with employers remaining accountable where third-party AI systems are used.

      Applicants and employees should have genuine human review where AI materially affects an adverse decision. Employers should remain accountable where third-party AI systems are used.

  14. Mr Mark Neugebauer Submission 361

    1. Have Parliament identify classes of decision affecting fundamental rights or significant interests in which AI may assist but not be the final authority, with rights to notice, explanation, challenge and human reconsideration.

      Parliament should identify classes of decision affecting fundamental rights or significant interests for which AI may assist human decision-making but should not become the final authority. Where AI materially influences consequential public decisions, citizens should have meaningful rights to notice, explanation, challenge and genuine human reconsideration.

  15. Mr Santhosh Kanaparthi Submission 418

    1. Provide accessible data/profile access, purpose/inference/recipient information, correction and consequential-use challenge; human reviewers need information, time and outcome-changing authority; do not present uncertain predictions as established facts.

      People should have accessible rights to know what data and profiles are held, understand their purposes, significant inferences and recipients, correct inaccuracies and challenge consequential use. Meaningful human review requires a reviewer with the information, time and authority to change the outcome. Uncertain predictions should not be presented as established facts.

  16. Name withheld Submission 485

    1. Individuals should have the right to know when AI has materially influenced an important decision and to have that decision reviewed by a genuine human decision-maker.

  17. Australian Renaissance Party Submission 532

    1. Legislate a right of human election for government and essential services: a person on the line within two minutes by phone or four by text, and a human arbitrator able to override any automated decision.

      Legislate a right of human election for government and essential services: a person on the line within two minutes by phone or four by text, and a human arbitrator able to override any automated decision.

  18. Community and Public Sector Union (CPSU) Submission 534

    1. Give individuals affected by AI-assisted decisions accessible, timely and enforceable rights to review and appeal.

      Individuals impacted by AI-assisted decisions must have accessible, timely and enforceable rights to review and appeal decisions.

Open in the interactive guide