AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Adopt a consistent assurance framework for consequential Commonwealth AI use

20 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.

Theme: AI use in Commonwealth agencies

Recommendations from submissions

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.

  1. Workday Submission 51

    1. Adopt policies advancing five enterprise-agent safeguards (persistent identity and authority, human oversight, data protection and security, auditable logs, assurance before deployment) as a checklist for AI-agent risk in Commonwealth adoption.

      Adopt policies that advance the five enterprise-agent safeguards — persistent identity and authority, rigorous human oversight, data protection and security, auditable logs, and assurance prior to deployment — as a practical checklist for evaluating AI-agent risk in Commonwealth department and agency adoption.

  2. Accenture Submission 52

    1. Require responsible AI controls across procurement, service design, data governance, cyber assurance, testing, training, monitoring/executive decisions for significant government deployments, with accountability, human review, audit trails and plain-language explanations for high-impact or public-facing uses.

      The Australian Government should require responsible AI controls to be embedded across procurement, service design, data governance, cyber assurance, testing, workforce training, monitoring and executive decision-making for significant government AI deployments, with clear accountability, human review rights, audit trails and plain-language public explanations for high-impact or public-facing uses.

  3. Transition Level Submission 78

    1. Require proportionate evidence of effective oversight for consequential Commonwealth AI deployments, through procurement and assurance processes.

      Require proportionate evidence of effective oversight for consequential Commonwealth AI deployments through procurement and assurance processes.

  4. Australian Fusion Industry Submission 150

    1. Require transparent Commonwealth AI procurement, documented human accountability, auditable decision pathways and effective review rights where decisions materially affect individuals or businesses.

      Require transparent Commonwealth AI procurement, documented human accountability, auditable decision pathways, and effective review rights where decisions materially affect individuals or businesses.

  5. Dr Gabrielle Josling Submission 156

    1. Apply mandatory AI transparency and assurance requirements to consequential AI use regardless of legal form, with a mechanism to extend them to corporate Commonwealth entities where AI materially affects individuals, influences decisions or involves sensitive information.

      Mandatory AI transparency and assurance requirements should apply to consequential AI use regardless of an entity’s legal form. The framework should provide a mechanism to extend relevant transparency and assurance requirements to corporate Commonwealth entities where AI use materially affects individuals, influences administrative decision-making, or involves sensitive information.

  6. Pledge Human (Good Humans Good Work) Submission 182

    1. For high-impact government AI, set proportionate requirements for transparency, impact assessment, human accountability, meaningful review and appeal.

      For high-impact government AI, this principle should translate into proportionate requirements for transparency, impact assessment, human accountability, meaningful review and appeal.

  7. NCC Group Submission 185

    1. Have Commonwealth procurement require, in proportion to capability, autonomy, access and consequence, dependency transparency, identity and access controls, human oversight, auditability, incident response, FOCI and jurisdictional risk, portability, continuity and independent assurance.

      Commonwealth procurement should reinforce this architecture through proportionate requirements for dependency transparency, identity and access, human oversight, auditability, incident response, FOCI and jurisdictional risk, portability, continuity and independent assurance. Requirements should scale with capability, autonomy, access and consequence.

  8. National Farmers' Federation Submission 188

    1. For higher-impact Commonwealth AI, require accountable decision-makers, meaningful human oversight, audit records, appropriate notice, accessible review, procurement assurance and independent evaluation; balance transparency against privacy, security and legitimate confidentiality.

      Government also bears heightened responsibilities because its decisions can affect rights, entitlements and access to essential services. The Committee should examine implementation of the Commonwealth policy for responsible use of AI, including accountable officials, transparency statements, internal registers, staff training, impact assessment and incident management. For higher-impact uses, minimum safeguards should include a legally accountable decision-maker, meaningful human oversight, records sufficient for audit, clear notice where appropriate, accessible review pathways, procurement assurance and independent evaluation. Transparency should be balanced against privacy, security and legitimate confidentiality.

  9. Australian Catholic University (ACU) Submission 211

    1. Require AI adoption in Commonwealth health-related services and administration to include clear accountability, transparent governance, appropriate human oversight and independent evaluation of safety, service quality, equity and workforce effects.

      Require AI adoption in Commonwealth health-related services and administration to include clear accountability, transparent governance, appropriate human oversight and independent evaluation of safety, service quality, equity and workforce effects.

  10. ServiceNow Submission 273

    1. Make governed autonomy standard for Commonwealth AI: one control tower over every agent, identity-scoped least-privilege access, complete audit trails, human oversight and a kill switch on every agent.

      Make governed autonomy the standard for Commonwealth AI use: a single AI control tower over every agent, identity-scoped least-privilege access, complete audit trails, human oversight, and a kill switch on every agent (ToR h).

  11. Monash University Submission 277

    1. Adopt a consistent Commonwealth assurance framework for AI adoption requiring public value, accountable officials, proportionate impact assessment, graduated testing, transparency, auditability, human review, contestability, redress and monitoring.

      a consistent Commonwealth assurance framework for AI adoption requiring clear public value, accountable officials, proportionate impact assessment, graduated testing, transparency, auditability, human review, contestability, redress and continuous monitoring

  12. Business Council of Australia (BCA) Submission 290

    1. Have Commonwealth agencies publish meaningful information about material AI use, apply proportionate impact assessment and assurance, and maintain accountable human oversight.

      Commonwealth agencies should publish meaningful information about material AI use, apply impact assessment and assurance proportionate to the decision or service, and maintain accountable human oversight.

      A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  13. Tech Council of Australia Submission 299

    1. Lead by example in government procurement and apply existing Commonwealth standards for its own AI use: accountable officials, use-case registers, impact assessments, staff training and risk-based governance.

      Lead by example in government procurement and apply existing Commonwealth standards for its own AI use, accountable AI officials, use-case registers, impact assessments, staff training and risk-based governance.

  14. Mr Stuart Le Gros Submission 344

    1. Make transparency, audit access, data portability, incident reporting and human-review capability mandatory conditions of Commonwealth procurement and grants.

      Use Commonwealth purchasing power. Make transparency, audit access, data portability, incident reporting and human-review capability mandatory conditions of Commonwealth procurement and grants.

  15. Ms Litsa Roberts Submission 352

    1. Require a mandatory AI Strategic Control Assessment for Commonwealth procurement and designated nationally critical or high-consequence AI uses, before approval, material expansion or renewal.

      For Commonwealth procurement and designated nationally critical or high-consequence uses of AI, including systems supporting critical infrastructure, essential government functions or significant rights and public interests, I recommend a mandatory AI Strategic Control Assessment before approval, material expansion or renewal.

  16. Mr Raffaele D'Angelo Submission 431

    1. For higher-impact Commonwealth AI uses, require a documented necessity and proportionality case, third-party impact assessment, written decision record, independent assurance and periodic review.

      For higher-impact Commonwealth AI uses, require a documented necessity and proportionality case, third-party impact assessment, written decision record, independent assurance and periodic review.

  17. Ms Heidi James Submission 436

    1. Subject Commonwealth AI adoption to strong transparency, privacy, security and accountability requirements, particularly where systems rely on foreign-developed models and datasets.

      The adoption of AI by Commonwealth departments and agencies must be subject to strong transparency, privacy, security and accountability requirements, particularly where systems are based on foreign-developed models and datasets.

  18. Mr David Hynes Submission 447

    1. Make conformance with the Guidance for AI Adoption and Australia's AI Ethics Principles a mandatory condition of Commonwealth AI procurement and use.

      conformance with the Guidance for AI Adoption and Australia's AI Ethics Principles as a mandatory condition of Commonwealth AI procurement and use,

  19. Mr Craig Thomler Submission 466

    1. Require Commonwealth assessments where AI materially influences rights, eligibility, employment, grants, procurement, compliance, enforcement or services, identifying accountable officials, AI role, model/data provenance, limitations, validation evidence, review rights, monitoring, recordkeeping and suspension.

      The Commonwealth should require accountability assessments where AI materially influences rights, eligibility, employment, grants, procurement, compliance, enforcement or access to services. It should identify the accountable official, the role of the AI, model and data provenance, limitations, validation evidence, review rights, monitoring, recordkeeping and suspension arrangements.

  20. Web Dance Submission 553

    1. Require independent assurance evidence, covering operating boundaries, monitoring and incident response, in Commonwealth procurement and deployment of AI, particularly agentic systems with network or system access, not only a supplier declaration.

      Commonwealth procurement and deployment of AI systems, particularly agentic systems with network or system access, should require independent assurance evidence covering operating boundaries, monitoring and incident response, not only a supplier declaration.

Open in the interactive guide