Keep existing copyright protections in place for AI training
11 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.
Theme: Copyright and AI training
Opposing asks
Listed in alphabetical order.
Recommendations from submissions
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.
Association of Artist Managers Submission 207
Preserve strong copyright protections as the primary AI policy objective, with artist protections complementing them.
AAM's position is unambiguous: the preservation of strong copyright protections is the first and most important objective in the current AI policy environment. Everything else in this section depends on it. These proposals are complementary to the copyright fight — they address what happens to artists once copyright is protected, not instead of protecting it.
Australian Music Industry Network (AMIN) Submission 216
Maintain and publicly reassert the position not to weaken Australian copyright laws.
AMIN urges the Australian Government to maintain, and to publicly reassert, their welcome stance as publicly stated by the Prime Minister in his July speech not to weaken our copyright laws.
Copyright Agency Submission 228
Resist suggestions that copyright should be replaced with another system.
The Government should resist suggestions, including those coming from the global technology sector, that copyright should be replaced with another system.
ABC Submission 304
Bind AI companies by the same copyright laws as other Australian media organisations to create a level playing field.
We submit AI should be bound by the same copyright laws as other Australian media organisations. There must bea level playing field for copyright users in the Australian media.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Australian Copyright Council (ACC) Submission 308
Maintain government support for Australia's creative industries and the existing rights of copyright owners, including their right to give or not give permission to use their work.
The ACC urges the government to maintain its support for Australia’s creative industries and the existing rights of copyright owners. Critical to that support is the right of creators/copyright owners to give (or not give) others permission to use their work.
Australian Society of Authors (ASA) Submission 312
Require multinational companies training AI onshore to abide by Australian law, stating no new legislative intervention is required for onshore training.
the Australian government must simply require multinational companies looking to train here to abide by our laws. No new legislative intervention is required with respect to onshore training.
Rightsholder Group Submission 329
Preserve the exclusive rights in Australia's copyright framework, with rightsholders retaining ownership and control over price, use and value.
It is key that the exclusive rights provided by Australia’s copyright framework are preserved, and that rightsholders retain ownership and control of their work. This includes the control over price, use and value.
Mr David Hynes Submission 447
Maintain licensing-first copyright.
R2 — Creator and content-integrity package: maintain licensing-first copyright;
Name withheld Submission 462
AI being trained or using peoples work without permission is unethical and should be considered in violation of copyright laws. Australia's decision to prohibit AI models from training on copyrighted Australian work without permission is one I am very pleased and grateful to see. As a creative person, it gives me hope and encouragement to make art and helps me feel safe to be creative. I support keeping these protections in place, and if there's any areas they could be improved to protect creatives more, I support that.
Thomson Reuters Submission 552
Support a copyright framework protecting human-created content in AI development and deployment and practical licensing for lawful commercial access to high-quality Australian content.
Thomson Reuters recommends that the Committee support a copyright and AI framework that: • preserves the application of copyright to protect human-created content used in AI development and deployment; • supports practical licensing mechanisms that allow AI developers to access high-quality Australian content on lawful commercial terms;
Mr Carl Gopalkrishnan Submission 563
Keep existing copyright protections in place rather than weakening them to accommodate AI corporations.
Australia's existing copyright laws provide important protections for artists. I support keeping those protections in place, rather than weakening them to accommodate AI corporations.