Rule out a text and data mining exception for AI training
11 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.
Theme: Text and data mining exception
Opposing asks
Listed in alphabetical order.
Recommendations from submissions
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.
Independent Music Publishers International Forum (IMPF) Submission 32
Do not introduce a commercial text and data mining exception.
There is no justification for introducing a commercial text and data mining exception.
GYRO.Group Submission 62
Endorse the Government's approach of ruling out a text and data mining exception in the Committee's report.
The Attorney-General's subsequent decision to rule out a text and data mining exception to the Copyright Act put that commitment into policy. GYRO.Group welcomes this, and we would encourage the Committee to endorse this approach in its report.
IFPI Submission 144
Maintain the authorisation-based copyright framework and reject any new TDM or AI-training exception.
maintain its authorisation-based copyright framework and reject any new TDM or AI-training exception;
Screenrights Submission 167
Do not introduce a copyright exception such as a text and data mining exception, or narrow copyright protections in favour of AI developers in a way that leaves rightsholders unremunerated.
Screenrights is strongly opposed to any form of copyright exception such as a text and data mining exception (TDM), or any narrowing of copyright protections in favour of AI developers that would leave rightsholders unremunerated.
National Association for the Visual Arts Submission 189
Maintain existing copyright protections and do not introduce a text and data mining exception.
NAVA supports maintaining existing copyright protections and the Australian Government’s commitment not to introduce a text and data mining exception.
Local & Independent News Association (LINA) Submission 197
Maintain the decision not to introduce a text and data mining exemption and avoid loopholes under alternative wording.
The Government must also maintain the decision not to introduce a text and data mining exemption, and ensure no exceptions under alternative wording allow for a loophole which would give AI developers free access to Australian publishers’ content.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Australasian Music Publishers' Association Limited (AMPAL) Submission 209
Reject any text and data mining exception, compulsory or extended collective licence, new AI-specific safe harbour, presumed mandate or requirement for rightsholders to opt out or deploy technology to preserve rights.
reject the implementation of any form of text and data mining (TDM) exception, compulsory or extended collective licence, new AI-specific safe harbour, presumed mandate or requirement for rightsholders to opt out or deploy technology to preserve existing rights.
Good Ancestors Submission 257
Progress an Australian copyright approach, not a text and data mining exception, allowing training in Australia while supporting rights holders.
Government should progress an Australian approach—not a text-and-data-mining exception—that supports rights holders while allowing training to occur in Australia.
Guardian Australia Submission 261
Reject statutory text and data mining exemptions and safe-harbour provisions for AI training, and affirm the right to refuse use and receive fair compensation.
Explicitly reject statutory text and data-mining exemptions and refuse any safe-harbour provisions to cover AI training or content ingestion. Ensure that the copyright holder is understood to have the right to refuse the use of content as well as a requirement they receive fair financial compensation for the use of their content by AI chatbots.
Australian Copyright Council (ACC) Submission 308
Reject any proposal amounting to an exception to infringement for AI activities using copyright material, however the exception is labelled or named.
the rejection of any proposal that amounts to an exception to infringement for AI activities utilising copyright protected material (regardless of how that exception is labelled or named),
Australian Publishers Association (APA) Submission 311
Reject a broad text-and-data-mining exception and oppose technical opt-outs and non-consensual training authorisations as substitutes for affirmative permission.
Maintain the rejection of a broad text and data mining exception and oppose technical opt-outs and non-consensual training authorisations as substitutes for affirmative permission.